Yes, you've (re)discovered the sad fact that, unfortunately, 800K Mac floppies cannot be written by a Windows floppy drive. The formats are so different at a fundamental level (including, but not limited to, zone-bit recording -- achieved in the original implementations by varying the spindle motor's speed) that an 800K Mac floppy must be written by a Mac floppy drive. No software cleverness can provide a workaround. So, you're right to go for Plan B and ask for someone to provide them to you.