I gave away a CRT monitor once on CraigsList, and it went pretty fast. I would just have to test the waters and see. A lot of people are trying to sell them for anywhere from $4 to $20 each. I might be able to sell nicer flat glass, 17" or 19" ones.
I have no problem parting out PCs, or Macs that have some flaw (ruined case, bad major component that I don't have lying about, etc.)
I will have access to a dumpster, so I can get rid of some non-toxic stuff that way. There's plenty of places that will take scrap metal and I can probably get some quotes and find who will pay the most.
It's not a viable plan in the long run, but it is probably sufficient for a one-off recycling drive. I'm pretty sure the city gets paid for each pallet of stuff that the bastard recycler takes away, so the city probably doesn't care, and I know for a fact that the recycler takes all the CRT monitors, palletizes them, and sends them away somewhere - he doesn't do any actual recycling of the monitors. He could be sending the stuff to India or something where little kids take them apart for scrap, but I don't think the city would affiliate themselves with a recycler who did that.
I still have a few other options for getting rid of the CRTs. Goodwill accepts CRTs; only larger newer flat front CRTs are sold in their shop and all others are recycled - Dell foots the bill, so I'm not disadvantaging Goodwill. I have taken about a dozen CRTs to Goodwill over time. There are also other recycling drives held by other companies, and some companies do take CRTs for free drop off, usually with a quantity limit.