Does this advice pertain to flash drive solutions? I ask because my IBM DGHS spinning platter drive is 4.5GB (i.e., "4GB and larger") and I formatted and partitioned it on my SE/30. I run System 6, 7 and 8 on it flawless. I have done so with the SE/30 in stock condition and upgraded. I too used the patched Apple HDSC app though.
In other words, I must assume the "reliability issue" being spoken of here is being directed merely at flash drive solutions for vintage Macs.