It looks too cartoony, you know with an outline around every single element.

[rant on the scroll arrows]
Look at the scroll "arrows", they make absolutely no sense. And dont try to make an argument like ,"just because they dont look like a scroll arrow doesnt make them bad, its pushing the idea of design standards"... because your right, its pushing the idea of a design standard right into the area of incomprehension. When something (such as the scroll arrows) differs from anything else available just for the sake of being different, THAT is amateurish. Sometimes doing something because no one elese is doing it is a bad a idea, especially when no one else is doing it for good reasons.
[/rant on the scroll arrows]