I agree. Just switched from Max's Milk theme to his Brushed theme. The Brushed theme is a perfect complement to the brushed look of Safari. I know some people don't like the brushed apprearance, but I LOVE it!

And I agree that if they had made the icons without the frames around them it would look even better (like Mail in the Brushed theme). But Adam has a point, it might look too crowded if it were any closer together than the layout in Mail. However, I put the toolbar icons in Mail next to those in Safari and they are almost identical in size. So it could still work. Man, I'm really enjoying that my browser looks like my other metal apps.