Skip to main content
Home Forums Al Jazeera office gets hit, here we go. — #23 Al Jazeera office gets hit, here we go. — #23
Post #23 by Logic
Post
Quote:
Originally posted by BkueKanoodle:
If you were indeed on the ground, as I have been, then you should know exactly how your fellow soldiers feel about people second guessing a situation they had no knowldege of. Thats my point, right now you only have information from one news source. You have no freakin idea went on there and for you to guess other wise would be Armchair Quarterbacking. Speculation, conjecture, guessing.

I'm not saying they were right or wrong, just offering alternatives to what you PRESUME to have happened. Who needs a floow up to this story confirm the facts, after all you've already made up your mind.

Me I give my boys the benefit of the doubt, and if I'm wrong later, then I'll admit it.


This is not something I get from one newssource. Almost every western media was in that building. They were filming the tanks on the bridge, and watching them engage the enemy here and there. Suddenly the tank aims at the hotel, pauses and then fires. The reporters in the building say they heard no fire coming from the hotel so what he was firing on we don't know. Then we got what the military is saying but that contradicts what the reporters at the site said. I trust them better than some general in Qatar.

I never said this was deliberatly done by the troops, it seems to have been a idiotic mistake. I'm sure they are doing their best in the situation. My guess is that they were under extreme pressure and very tense. Then they see some guy up in a building holding something big on his shoulder so they immediatly think anti-tank missile. They shoot. But the fact remains that they have the intel needed to avoid this. They knew that exactly that building houses press. One more second of thinking and a deep breath would probably have avoided this. You will probably say that exactly that extra second is something they don't have. I somewhat agree with you but the fact remains that they are in an urban area where civilians are. That extra second is something you should take to assure you when in doubt that you are not taking out a civilian.
mp.ls