For even more fighting fun, here's another list from Digital Dream Door: 1. Jimi Hendrix* - Jimi Hendrix Experience 2. Jeff Beck - Yardbirds, Jeff Beck Group, Solo 3. Eric Clapto…

No Dave Navarro in that one either? pfft.

Quote: Originally posted by Zimphire: No Dave Navarro in that one either? pfft. having a hot wife doesnt qualify you as a guitar god. sift through the hype zimp…

Quote: Originally posted by d4nth3m4n: mark knopfler is too low. No kidding. He should definitely be above The Edge, Jerry Garcia, Johnny Ramone, and Kurt Cobain. …

Quote: Originally posted by ringo: Same for The Edge (#24) being rated above Tom Morello (#26) Knowing a bit about Morello, I'm sure he'd agree with the ranking. Edg…

Quote: Originally posted by d4nth3m4n: having a hot wife doesnt qualify you as a guitar god. sift through the hype zimph. Pick up a copy of the Deconstruction alb…

Joni Mitchell is on this list (#72)? That's the name that to me looks out of place.

Quote: Originally posted by Dr. Wahnsinn: Harrison listed but not Lennon? As a guitarist, Harrison was leaps and bounds better than Lennon. This is about guitar, not…

You can't compare guitarists like this. You have to AT LEAST group them by genre. There are just too many styles out there, and you can't compare them. Same goes for ANY instrument…

No Brian May?? Hello?

David Gilmour #82? I think the general consensus here is Rolling Stone's list is pure crap. I like the Digital Dream Door one much better.

I don't mean to hijack your thread but while looking for that article I found this. You California people have all the luck. Looks like a great line up. Ramones to Hold 30th Anni…

Quote: Originally posted by voodoo: No Brian May?? Hello? #39 on the Rolling Stone list

Quote: Originally posted by voodoo: No Brian May?? Hello? Yeah him too.. This list just stinks.

To rank Joan Jett above Angus Young is just....wrong

Quote: Originally posted by spacefreak: As a guitarist, Harrison was leaps and bounds better than Lennon. This is about guitar, not songwriting. I know that I'…

I like the list. It makes sense to me that a lot of the people listed are there in their respective ranking. Joni Mitchell: if you've ever seen her play and sing, you'd realize imm…

if you want to get folky, ani surely crushes joni.

Quote: Originally posted by awaspaas: David Gilmour #82? I think the general consensus here is Rolling Stone's list is pure crap.(snip) ditto

Quote: Originally posted by spacefreak: As a guitarist, Harrison was leaps and bounds better than Lennon. This is about guitar, not songwriting. thats really stup…

Quote: Originally posted by MacGorilla: To rank Joan Jett above Angus Young is just....wrong Yeah, like, he knows 2 more chords than her.

Quote: Originally posted by MacNStein: Yeah, like, he knows 2 more chords than her. five chords and the truth?

Quote: Originally posted by d4nth3m4n: five chords and the truth? The truth: don't mix Bushmills with Milwaukee's Be[a]st.

That first list is total ********. Angus Young, Eddie Van Halen�!!? So low! 70's and 90's?! That's ridiculous! The second list is even more messed up. Who put Kirk at 59?! Digita…

Quote: Originally posted by MacNStein: The truth: don't mix Bushmills with Milwaukee's Be[a]st. Just reading that gave me a headache.