Trust me, I know why we all have cabinets full of old cables.
Tucson isn't a very big city, but I can definitely get db9 and db25 null modem adapters at the one and only electronic parts store in town. It might be worth a look.
Also, I don't really think the presence (or lack) of shielding should be impacting the OP in this situation unless he's in some very harsh rf environment. I agree that ZMODEM is worth trying.