With many people 'switching' from PC to Mac with the arrival of the mini, I wondered what these new computer-literate users make of the platform? Hoping to get a thread not biased by Mac zealots - but an unbiased opinion on the platform.
Here's my take...
Mini arrived last week (1.25GHz, 512 MB, 80GB, SuperDrive, Bluetooth, Airport Extreme with Apple Pro Wireless mouse and keyboard.)
Connected it to my iiyama 19" CRT.
Wasn't quite as 'plug and play' as I thought. After switch-on, could not get the past the language-selection screen as the mouse and keyboard weren't recognised. No 'quick-start' pull-out and only a reference in the printed user-guide to 'refer to the documentation with the wireless mouse and keyboard'. These advised bringing up 'system preferences' - which I could not access.
...had to call Apple Technical Support (5 mins waiting time only) to be told that the Mac OS X setup disk had to be in the drive when the mini booted first time - this wasn't mentioned clearly enough in the printed user-guide (if it was mentioned at all.)
The iiyama monitor is detected very well by OS X - a resolution of 1152 x 864 at 75 Hz is chosen. The manual states that 1280x 1024 is the 'preferred resolution' (this is the maximum true resolution possible given the dot-pitch of the monitor - though it will render up to a dizzying 2048 x 1600.) Since 1280 x 1024 is a 5:4 ratio resolution - and the monitor is a 4:3 resolution, the choice OS X makes is very good indeed.
Running 'Display Calibration Assistant' shows that the monitor is very close to passing all the tests to ensure a target gamma of 1.8 - only a minor tweak to the black level is required (possibly due to the fact the monitor is nearly 2 years old now.)
So overall, the Mac runs a fully-callibrated display as default - compared to Windows XP default choice of 800x600 (with a pop-up bubble changing the resolution to 1024x768 on this same monitor) and the Mac clearly is superior.
Impressed by Safari's choice of large fonts for screen reading - browsers should optimise for screen reading and not have to worry about true print WYSIWYG.
Unimpressed by Safari's speed - going to try out Firefox and Camino to see if the rendering speed is Safari-specific.
Internet Setup Assistant at first setup immediatelt recognised by Netgear Wireless router - no problems wth Airport capability, and surfing in 15 mins.
Transfered all by pictures taken on Nokia camera phone to mini via bluetooth - fancy, but not impressed by speed (7k/sec, when each picure is arond 300k, and there are 185 pics to transfer!.) Bluetooth functionality is easy to use though.
Very impressed by iPhoto slideshow of pics, with various effects and music picked from music folder done in literally minutes.
Not impressed by downloading on OS X - files appear on the desktop without anouncing download finished - many times download a file multiple times to the desktop thinking the link is broken.
Find myself dragging a lot using the mouse - windows don't maximise to the whole screen making the whole environment more 'windowed'. The Apple mouse stops the context menu being used so much - so I find I literally drag to the trash can, to folders etc. The Apple mouse encourages a more-ergonomic position of holding the mouse (the wrist moves less.) So I guess that's a better arrangement.
Installed route 66 - only to find that the icon wasn't put in the 'Applications' folder or the Dock. I can see many newer users getting confused by aplciations not appearing immediately in the Dock.
Notice tool tips take longer to appear - maybe to keep the screen from 'cluttering' easily during normal use - but make discovering program features longer.
Notice 'home and 'end' keys don't move to the beginning and end of a line as in Windows - I miss that.
My sister bought an eMac recently. This was an attempt to get her an easier computer to use in the hope she wouldn't keep calling me to repair it. A month after getting it, she reports unusable icons all over the desktop, unable to install WMP 9 and increasing frequency of 'hangs'. OS X seems to be less wizard-driven than Windows - and usability suffers as a result in my opinion.
Impressed by how OS X never seems to slow down, regardless of the number of apps running.
Enough for now - overall, I'm pleased with my purchase. The ergonomics of my new system are better than they are on the PC - and tha's a big plus point. I don't think that the Mac is really easier for a complete newb to use though compared to Windows.
Anyone else's thoughts on 'the switch'?
Here's my take...
Mini arrived last week (1.25GHz, 512 MB, 80GB, SuperDrive, Bluetooth, Airport Extreme with Apple Pro Wireless mouse and keyboard.)
Connected it to my iiyama 19" CRT.
Wasn't quite as 'plug and play' as I thought. After switch-on, could not get the past the language-selection screen as the mouse and keyboard weren't recognised. No 'quick-start' pull-out and only a reference in the printed user-guide to 'refer to the documentation with the wireless mouse and keyboard'. These advised bringing up 'system preferences' - which I could not access.
...had to call Apple Technical Support (5 mins waiting time only) to be told that the Mac OS X setup disk had to be in the drive when the mini booted first time - this wasn't mentioned clearly enough in the printed user-guide (if it was mentioned at all.)
The iiyama monitor is detected very well by OS X - a resolution of 1152 x 864 at 75 Hz is chosen. The manual states that 1280x 1024 is the 'preferred resolution' (this is the maximum true resolution possible given the dot-pitch of the monitor - though it will render up to a dizzying 2048 x 1600.) Since 1280 x 1024 is a 5:4 ratio resolution - and the monitor is a 4:3 resolution, the choice OS X makes is very good indeed.
Running 'Display Calibration Assistant' shows that the monitor is very close to passing all the tests to ensure a target gamma of 1.8 - only a minor tweak to the black level is required (possibly due to the fact the monitor is nearly 2 years old now.)
So overall, the Mac runs a fully-callibrated display as default - compared to Windows XP default choice of 800x600 (with a pop-up bubble changing the resolution to 1024x768 on this same monitor) and the Mac clearly is superior.
Impressed by Safari's choice of large fonts for screen reading - browsers should optimise for screen reading and not have to worry about true print WYSIWYG.
Unimpressed by Safari's speed - going to try out Firefox and Camino to see if the rendering speed is Safari-specific.
Internet Setup Assistant at first setup immediatelt recognised by Netgear Wireless router - no problems wth Airport capability, and surfing in 15 mins.
Transfered all by pictures taken on Nokia camera phone to mini via bluetooth - fancy, but not impressed by speed (7k/sec, when each picure is arond 300k, and there are 185 pics to transfer!.) Bluetooth functionality is easy to use though.
Very impressed by iPhoto slideshow of pics, with various effects and music picked from music folder done in literally minutes.
Not impressed by downloading on OS X - files appear on the desktop without anouncing download finished - many times download a file multiple times to the desktop thinking the link is broken.
Find myself dragging a lot using the mouse - windows don't maximise to the whole screen making the whole environment more 'windowed'. The Apple mouse stops the context menu being used so much - so I find I literally drag to the trash can, to folders etc. The Apple mouse encourages a more-ergonomic position of holding the mouse (the wrist moves less.) So I guess that's a better arrangement.
Installed route 66 - only to find that the icon wasn't put in the 'Applications' folder or the Dock. I can see many newer users getting confused by aplciations not appearing immediately in the Dock.
Notice tool tips take longer to appear - maybe to keep the screen from 'cluttering' easily during normal use - but make discovering program features longer.
Notice 'home and 'end' keys don't move to the beginning and end of a line as in Windows - I miss that.
My sister bought an eMac recently. This was an attempt to get her an easier computer to use in the hope she wouldn't keep calling me to repair it. A month after getting it, she reports unusable icons all over the desktop, unable to install WMP 9 and increasing frequency of 'hangs'. OS X seems to be less wizard-driven than Windows - and usability suffers as a result in my opinion.
Impressed by how OS X never seems to slow down, regardless of the number of apps running.
Enough for now - overall, I'm pleased with my purchase. The ergonomics of my new system are better than they are on the PC - and tha's a big plus point. I don't think that the Mac is really easier for a complete newb to use though compared to Windows.
Anyone else's thoughts on 'the switch'?
)